protein, carbohydrates and fats
Updated: Jun 28
Food and appetite
Understanding how food works in the body in relation to appetite, satiety and energy expenditure can be a useful mechanism to harness when thinking about using ‘Food as Medicine’ in the context of weight loss and health.
The energy value of nutrients
Obesity is a state which occurs when the body has accumulated excess body fat. This happens gradually over time and reflects a chronic energy imbalance whereby energy intake exceeds expenditure.
Energy intake is derived from the consumption of food and drinks. Different foods and drinks differ in the amount of energy they supply because they are made up of different proportions of macronutrients.
The three main macronutrients: carbohydrate, protein and fat as well as alcohol and dietary fibre, each contributes a different amount of energy. Carbohydrate provides 16 KJ/gram (or 4 calories/gram). Protein provides 17 KJ/gram (4 calories per gram), fat provides 37 KJ/gram (9 calories per gram) and alcohol provides 29 KJ/gram (7 calories/gram).
If your intake of dietary energy is greater than your actual energy needs, this will lead ultimately to fat storage.
Components of Energy Expenditure
Energy expenditure is how much energy you use up. It is composed of three major components.
Resting Metabolic Rate (energy needed for body functioning) contributes 60% to 70% of your total Energy Expenditure.
Physical Activity (energy for body movement) can be quite variable but often makes up 20% to 30% of your total Energy Expenditure.
Thermic Effect of Food (energy required to digest meals) uses up around 10% of energy expenditure.
Additional energy is also required for growth. The rate of growth is the highest during infancy, then by early childhood growth velocity slows right down until a marked growth spurt occurs during adolescence.
This again leads to higher energy needs, but by 20 years of age the additional energy needed for growth has dropped to zero so any excess energy that is not expended in activity will be stored as body fat.
Components of total energy expenditure
The energy cost of digesting and assimilating food
The thermic effect of food is the ‘energy-cost’ required for food to be digested in the gut and assimilated into the bloodstream. This energy cost is sometimes also known as meal induced thermogenesis. Different macronutrients take different amounts of energy to digest and assimilate.
In adults, the thermic effect of protein is 20% to 30%, compared with carbohydrate 5% to 15% and fat 0% to 3%, From this you can see that a high protein meal will require more energy to digest compared to one that is lower in protein.
This fact has stimulated research into whether a high protein diet is better to assist people to lose weight.
What does the body do with food after it is consumed?
In the gut, food is broken down or digested into component macronutrients and absorbed. Absorbed nutrients then follow one of two pathways: they will either be oxidised to provide energy immediately or they will be stored so that they can provide energy at some time in the future. Some macronutrients are more readily oxidised than others.
There appears to be a hierarchy: carbohydrate and protein are oxidised first while fat is oxidised later.
This seems to be because the body does not store protein (protein only accumulates where it is being actively used - which is why you lose muscle if you are not using it) and the body has only a very limited storage capacity for carbohydrate.
Alcohol is also oxidised immediately after it is consumed to try and eliminate it because alcohol is toxic to the body and cannot be stored. In comparison to these macronutrients, fat can very easily be stored in almost unlimited amounts all around the body.
Due to the body’s selection of carbohydrate and protein as first targets for oxidation, carbohydrate oxidation and protein closely track with carbohydrate intake and protein intake, respectively.
In contrast, fat intake does not immediately stimulate fat oxidation but instead can be readily diverted to be stored.
Appetite and Satiety
We eat more food when we are hungry as we respond to our appetite. Different macronutrients seem to differ in their impact on our appetite sensations. Protein quickly settles our appetite and promotes greater satiety or feelings of fullness than carbohydrate and fat.
High protein meals therefore have more ability to reduce energy intake from a meal, as well as intake from the next meal than do meals that are low in protein.
The reason for this difference is that macronutrients are not all equally able to stimulate the release of the hormones from the gut that are required to stimulate appetite. Ghrelin (a gut hormone that stimulates hunger) appears to be suppressed more effectively by carbohydrates or proteins than it is by fat.
In addition, protein and carbohydrates are more effective at stimulating GLP-1 (a gut hormone that promotes fullness) than is fat. Protein also induces the strongest release of PYY (another gut hormone that promotes sensations of fullness).